Company News
Why Chefs Should Choose Real Sea Salt Over Rock Salt and Table Salt
Salt is one of the most fundamental ingredients in any professional kitchen. Used in almost every style of cooking, it...
Company News
When it comes to providing school meals, choosing the right catering arrangement is an important decision. Schools need to balance food quality, nutritional standards, affordability and the day-to-day practicalities of running a busy kitchen.
For many years, schools have relied on local authority catering services or large contract catering companies to manage their meal provision. However, with some local authorities changing or withdrawing their school meal services, schools are increasingly exploring alternative ways to feed their pupils.
The good news is that there is more than one way to provide school meals. From employing an in-house catering team to partnering with an independent foodservice wholesaler, schools have a range of options to consider.
In this guide, we explore the different approaches to school meal provision, the advantages and considerations of each, and how schools can find the right solution for their pupils, staff and budgets.
Contract catering is one of the most established approaches to school meal provision. Under this arrangement, a school appoints an external catering company to manage some or all aspects of its meal service.
This may include employing catering staff, planning menus, purchasing ingredients, preparing meals and managing the daily operation of the kitchen.
Large contract caterers can offer a comprehensive service, which may be particularly appealing to schools that do not have the time or resources to manage catering independently.
Contract catering can be convenient, but schools should carefully consider the terms of their agreement.
The level of flexibility available may depend on the contract. Schools may have less direct control over menu choices, food sourcing and how the service operates.
It is also important to understand the full financial arrangement, including management fees, meal prices, minimum requirements and how any financial risks or surpluses are managed.
For schools that want greater involvement in their food provision, a fully managed contract may not always be the most suitable approach.
One common concern for schools considering a move to contract catering is what will happen to their existing kitchen team.
In many cases, existing catering staff can transfer to the new provider under a process known as TUPE (Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment)).
TUPE is UK employment legislation designed to protect employees when a business or service transfers to a new employer. Where the regulations apply, employees assigned to the catering service will generally transfer to the incoming provider automatically.
This means that appointing a contract catering company does not necessarily mean losing an experienced kitchen team or starting again with new staff.
Will staff keep their existing pay and conditions?
Where TUPE applies, employees generally retain their existing contractual terms and conditions, including basic pay, contractual benefits, holiday entitlement and continuity of service.
The new employer cannot simply reduce employees’ pay or change their contracts because of the transfer itself, although certain changes may be permitted in specific circumstances.
What about pensions?
Pensions are another important consideration, particularly for staff who are members of the Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS).
Pension benefits already built up are protected. Depending on the circumstances and applicable pension protection requirements, the new provider may also need to offer access to the LGPS or provide a broadly comparable pension arrangement for future service.
The precise arrangements can vary, so schools should seek specialist employment and pension advice before agreeing to a transfer.
Does every contract caterer have to apply TUPE?
TUPE is not an optional policy adopted by individual catering companies. It is a legal requirement when the conditions for a qualifying transfer are met.
It may apply when a school moves from local authority catering to a private provider, or when one contract caterer replaces another. However, it does not automatically apply to every catering contract. The specific circumstances, including how the existing service is organised and which employees are assigned to it, must be assessed.
Schools should establish whether TUPE applies before making a change and ensure that any prospective provider understands its responsibilities.
Another option is for a school to manage its own catering service by employing its own kitchen staff and taking responsibility for the preparation and delivery of meals.
This approach gives schools greater control over their catering operation and allows them to build a service around their pupils’ needs.
Managing catering in-house also comes with additional responsibilities.
Schools must consider recruitment, staff training, food safety, allergen management, menu planning, purchasing, stock control and kitchen management.
There is also the challenge of sourcing food at competitive prices. Without established purchasing arrangements, individual schools may find it more difficult to access the range, pricing and buying power available to larger catering organisations.
For schools that have the kitchen facilities and catering staff in place, however, managing their own provision can offer a valuable opportunity to create a service that works specifically for them.
A third option is to operate an independent school meal service supported by a foodservice wholesaler.
Under this model, the school retains responsibility for its catering operation, including employing its kitchen staff and preparing meals, while partnering with a wholesale food supplier to source the ingredients it needs.
This can offer a middle ground between a fully managed contract catering service and managing every aspect of food procurement independently.
Rather than handing over the catering operation to an external company, schools can maintain control of their menus, kitchen teams and food preparation while benefiting from the support of an established foodservice supplier.
Greater control over food and menus
Schools can decide what they serve, how meals are prepared and which ingredients they use. This can be particularly valuable for schools committed to scratch cooking, seasonal menus or catering that reflects the needs of their pupils.
Access to a wide range of products
A foodservice wholesaler can supply ingredients across frozen, chilled and ambient categories, as well as fresh fruit and vegetables and non-food essentials.
This allows schools to source a broad range of products through one supplier, helping to simplify purchasing.
Competitive purchasing
Independent wholesalers can offer access to established buying networks and competitive pricing. This can help schools manage ingredient costs without needing to purchase everything individually from multiple suppliers.
Flexibility to suit the school
Schools can choose how they operate their catering service, whether that involves daily scratch cooking, a combination of fresh and prepared ingredients or a menu designed around specific dietary needs.
Ongoing support
A good foodservice partner can provide more than just deliveries. Product advice, menu planning support, nutritional information, allergen data and help identifying cost-effective alternatives can all contribute to a successful catering operation.
Keeping existing catering staff
One of the advantages of this approach is that schools can continue employing their own catering teams. If they are simply changing food suppliers rather than transferring the catering service to a new employer, the change of supplier alone would not normally trigger TUPE.
Existing employment and pension arrangements can therefore remain in place because the school continues to employ its staff.
Independent provision does require the school to have the appropriate catering staff, facilities and management processes in place.
The school remains responsible for the operation of its kitchen and ensuring that its food provision meets the relevant requirements.
However, for schools that want to retain control without taking on the expense or limitations of a fully managed catering contract, this model can be an attractive alternative.
Schools do not necessarily have to make these decisions alone.
Some schools, academies and Multi-Academy Trusts choose to manage catering across several sites, sharing purchasing arrangements, expertise or resources.
This can help smaller schools benefit from economies of scale while retaining more control than they might have under a fully outsourced contract.
For example, schools within a trust could coordinate their food purchasing through a single wholesaler, share menu development resources and establish consistent standards across their kitchens.
This approach can be particularly useful where individual schools have limited purchasing power or catering management resources.
| Catering model | Who manages the kitchen? | Menu control | Main consideration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contract caterer | External catering company | Usually shared or contract-dependent | Convenience and reduced management responsibility |
| In-house catering | School-employed team | High | Requires internal management and expertise |
| Independent provision with a wholesaler | School-employed team | High | School manages catering but receives supply-chain support |
| Multi-school or trust provision | School or trust catering team | High, often coordinated | Requires collaboration and central organisation |
There is no single catering model that is right for every school. The best approach will depend on the school’s facilities, staffing, budget, meal uptake and the level of control it wants to retain.
Before making a decision, schools should assess their current provision and identify what they want to achieve.
Some important questions include:
It is also important to consider the transition process. Schools changing providers should review existing contracts, staffing arrangements, procurement requirements and any relevant TUPE or pension obligations before making a change.
Regardless of the catering model chosen, schools must ensure that their food provision meets the relevant requirements.
In England, state schools must comply with the national School Food Standards. These cover the types of food and drink that should be provided, helping to ensure that pupils receive balanced and nutritious meals.
Schools should also consider allergen management, food safety, appropriate staff training and the wider role of food in supporting pupil wellbeing.
Choosing an alternative catering model does not remove these responsibilities. Instead, schools need to ensure that the right processes and expertise are in place to manage them effectively.
With changing local authority services and increasing pressure on school budgets, it is understandable that schools are reviewing their catering arrangements.
A contract catering company may offer the convenience of a fully managed service. In-house catering can provide greater control but requires the school to manage the operation itself. Independent school meal provision, supported by a foodservice wholesaler, offers another approach for schools that want to retain control while benefiting from professional supply-chain support.
For schools with an existing kitchen and catering team, working with an independent wholesaler could provide the flexibility to build a catering service around their own pupils, menus and budget.
At Trevors Foodservice, we understand the importance of providing schools with reliable access to quality ingredients, competitive pricing and dependable deliveries.
As an independent foodservice wholesaler serving schools across the North West, we can help school catering teams source the products they need to deliver nutritious, appealing and affordable meals.
Whether your school is reviewing its current catering contract, preparing to take its meal provision in-house or looking for a more flexible food supply arrangement, exploring your options is a worthwhile first step.
Looking for an alternative to contract catering?
Get in touch with Trevors Foodservice to discuss how we could support your school’s catering team.